Trafigura's nickel case: paying against documents for metal nobody had seen
Trafigura paid about US$500 million for nickel cargoes that turned out to hold steel. A London court has called it fraud. What the structure got wrong, and what the recovery got right.
In January, the Commercial Court in London ruled that Trafigura had been the victim of a large nickel fraud. The trading house had paid about US$500 million for 107 cargoes of what the paperwork called high-grade nickel. When containers were opened in Rotterdam at the end of 2022, they held carbon steel. Others later turned out to hold stainless steel plates, aluminium ingots or iron briquettes. The judgment is a story about one dishonest counterparty. It is also a story about a payment structure that let paper stand in for metal for far too long.
How the trades worked
Between October 2021 and August 2022, Trafigura signed nine master contracts with companies linked to Prateek Gupta, a businessman based in Dubai. The companies sold it LME-grade nickel, which must be at least 99.8% pure, on CIF terms in monthly lots. Trafigura usually paid 90% of each provisional invoice within three business days of receiving a full set of documents: bills of lading, the seller's invoice, a certificate of analysis and an insurance certificate.
That is a normal way to buy a cargo. It means the buyer pays when the goods are shipped, not when they arrive. It also means the buyer pays before anyone on its side has seen the metal. Every one of those documents described nickel. According to the court, the bills of lading and insurance certificates were false.
The flow was large and partly financed. In the relevant period Trafigura did 542 trades with the group, worth about US$3.3 billion, with bank financing from Citi behind some of them. Gupta later claimed an informal deal under which his companies would buy the cargoes back. The court found no such deal existed. The judge also noted that a repurchase that was not an obligation would have given the sellers a free option, and Trafigura would in substance have been making a gift of its money.
What broke
The warning signs came during 2022. Trafigura's nickel trader pressed for independent inspections of a share of the cargoes, and Citi ended its financing in October. On 9 November a sample of containers was opened in Rotterdam and found to hold carbon steel. On 22 December eight more containers there told the same story. In February 2023 Trafigura announced a charge of US$577 million, its estimate of the maximum loss. The material in the 91 main cargoes was later sold for under US$10 million, about 2% of what Trafigura had paid for them.
A bill of lading proves that someone said something was loaded. It does not prove what is inside the box.
The structure had three weak points, and they compounded each other. Payment was triggered by documents that one counterparty controlled. The contract's own inspection right ran for 30 days after arrival, so physical checks came after the money had gone. And the exposure built up with a single group, cargo by cargo, over many months, without an obligation on that group to take the goods back. Nickel made it worse. It is dense and expensive, so a container of the wrong metal can look about right on a weighbridge while being worth a fraction of the invoice.
What the recovery got right
Trafigura's response is the other half of the case. It went public early and booked the full exposure rather than drip-feeding losses. It issued its claim in London on 8 February 2023 and obtained a worldwide freezing order the same day, which Gupta later failed to set aside. In April 2025 it secured a separate freezing order in the courts of the Dubai International Financial Centre.
Gupta's defence was unusual. He accepted that the cargoes were not nickel but argued that senior Trafigura staff had devised the scheme, so Trafigura could not complain. The judge rejected that, found that the employees involved were honest victims, and said he did not find Gupta an honest witness. The court ordered restitution of about US$489.8 million on the main cargoes, net of what the substitute metal fetched, with further claims on the remaining trades. Several of the companies are now in liquidation or dissolved, so the next phase, tracing where the money went, matters as much as the judgment.
Courts do not always agree. A Dubai criminal court convicted Gupta of forgery in June 2024, but the conviction was overturned on appeal and the acquittal was later upheld. A civil judgment in London is a strong claim. Collecting on it across jurisdictions is a separate and slower task.
Questions to ask
- Who issues the documents you pay against, and does any of them come from a party independent of the seller?
- When does someone acting for you see the goods: before payment, at loading, or only at destination?
- How much can one counterparty owe you, in cargoes paid for but not yet inspected, before someone has to sign off?
- If a deal is really financing, does the contract oblige the other side to buy the goods back?
- If it goes wrong, where are the counterparty's assets, and how quickly could you freeze them?
Sources
- [Trafigura Pte Ltd & Anor v Prateek Gupta & Ors, [2026] EWHC 159 (Comm), The National Archives](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/comm/2026/159)
- Trafigura: Statement re legal action (30 January 2026, with the 9 February 2023 statement)
- Hill Dickinson: Commodity trader successful in fraudulent nickel trade claims (11 February 2026)
- Global Trade Review: In-depth, Trafigura wins blockbuster Gupta fraud claim (4 February 2026)
- Global Trade Review: Gupta was convicted, then acquitted, in Dubai over Trafigura fraud (25 August 2026)
- Bloomberg: Trafigura was victim of a nickel fraud on a grand scale, judge says (30 January 2026)
Informational content only. Not investment advice.